It’s part of summer as sure as the days get longer. When the season is over and Scottish sports columns need to be filled up with football stories, we get talk of either an Atlantic League or the possibility of the Old Firm moving to the English leagues. Could the latter happen?
Well, I think it’s quite likely one day. Basically, where there’s a will there’s a way. It’s become quite clear over the years that it’s a proposition which leaves many associated with the Old Firm licking their chops.
The Scottish summer has come early this year and not just because of some decent weather. Bolton chairman Phil Gartside has raised the possibility of Celtic and Rangers joining a two-tier Premiership. UEFA have as good as said it is not their business and the matter will be discussed at the EPL’s annual general meeting in June.
The EPL doesn’t really need the Old Firm at the moment, but there will come a time when they look to spice things up and generate new interest. This would be one obvious way. It would seem that the possibility has a long way to go but if it does eventually happen where would that leave the SPL?
I was surprised to read in a poll in the Daily Record that currently says that almost 56% think that Scottish football would be better off if the Old Firm moved to England. First of all, we should be clear that many readers of the Daily Record are Old Firm fans. Are they voting yes simply because they wan the Old Firm to go to the EPL or do they really believe the rest of Scottish football would be better off without them?
Secondly, it has to be asked what is meant by better off? If they mean financially richer then I think the answer has to be a resounding No for current SPL clubs. Television and sponsorship money would be harder to come by and that’s almost bread and butter these days.
It might be more difficult to attract better players from outside the country as a few visits a season to the Ibrox and Celtic Park must be one of the big attractions of playing in Scotland. The shop window aspect of attracting a bigger club would also be somewhat reduced and even the odd Champions League qualifier isn’t likely to be that much of a carrot.
Leaving aside the politics of such a shakeup could affect the status of the national team, there are other respects in which the Scottish game would go on much as normal. For instance, many of Scotland’s better players have always ended up in Glasgow or England anyway, so what’s the difference there?
If by “better off” we mean more competitive and more interesting then I think that would be the case without a doubt. And some of the bigger remaining clubs: Aberdeen, Dundee United, Hearts, Hibs (and possibly two or three others on the odd occasion), might be able to call upon healthy crowds because they could challenge for the league championship. It might also leave the door open for league reconstruction and a return to a bigger league. Top flight football could help clubs like Dundee, St. Johnstone, Partick Thistle, Dunfermline, Morton and Livingston or Queen of the South.


